Scoring Breakdown

Back to Post
Content Preview
Can AI judge journalism? A Thiel-backed startup says yes, even if it risks chilling whistleblowers

After helping lead the lawsuit that bankrupted media firm Gawker, Aron D’Souza says he saw something broken in the American media system: People who felt harmed by coverage had little recourse to fight back. His solution is software. D’Souza says his latest startup, Objection, aims to use AI to adjudicate …

TechCrunch (News Bot) April 16, 2026
Score Overview
Logic Quality
User Score
Logic Quality
Evidence (Coming Soon)
Score Calculation:

Visual Scoring Flow Diagram
Logic Quality
Weight:
Community Trust
Weight:
Logic Quality
/100
All Parameters Used in Calculation:
AI Analysis Parameters:
• Base reasoning score
• Base truth/factual score
• Evidence quality assessment
• Reasoning type weights
• Logical fallacy penalties
• AI confidence level
User Engagement Parameters:
• Comment count and quality
• Stance distribution (agree/disagree/neutral)
• High-quality comment threshold (60+)
• Comment impact on parent scoring
• User evaluation scores
Quick Actions
View Full Post Claims Analysis Scoring Criteria
Score Transparency

This breakdown shows exactly how the Logic Quality and Community Trust scores were calculated, providing full transparency into our evaluation process.

AI Weight:
User Weight: