Scoring Breakdown

Back to Post
Content Preview
Manual Post - by Miles Navarro

Just lost a brutal round of Catan. Thought I had the perfect strategy lined up—until someone slipped in with a sneaky settlement and flipped the whole board against me. And it hit me: this is exactly how today’s “debates” play out. It’s not about who’s got the best plan or …

Miles Navarro September 05, 2025
Score Overview
Logic Quality
User Score
Logic Quality
Evidence (Coming Soon)
Score Calculation:

Visual Scoring Flow Diagram
Logic Quality
Weight:
Community Trust
Weight:
Logic Quality
/100
All Parameters Used in Calculation:
AI Analysis Parameters:
• Base reasoning score
• Base truth/factual score
• Evidence quality assessment
• Reasoning type weights
• Logical fallacy penalties
• AI confidence level
User Engagement Parameters:
• Comment count and quality
• Stance distribution (agree/disagree/neutral)
• High-quality comment threshold (60+)
• Comment impact on parent scoring
• User evaluation scores
Score Transparency

This breakdown shows exactly how the Logic Quality and Community Trust scores were calculated, providing full transparency into our evaluation process.

AI Weight:
User Weight: