Emails from Prince Andrew
1. “How’s LA? Have you found me some new inappropriate friends?” — Email from “A” signed “A xxx” sent from Balmoral.
2. “The Girls are completely shattered…” — referring to people in his company.
3. “I am up here at Balmoral… Activities take place all day and I am totally exhausted…” — self-description near the start of the note.
4. “…I am free from 25th August until 2nd Sept and want to go somewhere hot and sunny with some fun people…” — continued request.
5. “So sorry to disappoint you… I have only been able to find appropriate friends.” — Maxwell’s reply.
6. “Distraught!” — response from “A” after Maxwell’s reply.
🤔 Your turn: Where’s the fallacy? Which thinking traps can you spot in these statements?
Logic Quality Breakdown:
- Raw_Score: 32.5
-
Factual Score: 30.0
Analysis: Partially supported claims
- Ai_Analysis:
- Final_Score: 32.5
- Analysis_Method:
- Fallacy_Penalty: -25.0
-
Reasoning Score: 27.5
Analysis: Moderate reasoning